Part 1
This experiment was quite difficult. Even though it is obvious that not being able to speak would make carrying a conversation challenging, I would have thought that using body language and other gestures would have helped more than it did.
After several minutes had passed, I had realized my partner was behaving differently. They seemed to be speaking more slowly and loudly, like you would to someone who speaks another language. It's strange, but I guess subconsciously they thought that since I was only gesturing and using body language, instead of speaking, that I also couldn't understand what they were saying.
If my partner and I represented two different cultures meeting for the first time, then the speaking culture would be better at communicating complex ideas. Using body language and gesturing can only get you so far; you could point to something you needed, or communicate your feelings through a shrug, frown, etc. But to have a conversation, especially if it is about complex or abstract ideas, you have to be able to use language.
I would assume that the speaking culture would look down on a culture that does not have a language. Throughout history, "civilized" nations saw people who were nomadic, spiritual, etc as "barbaric", simply because they held different values or had a different lifestyle than them.
Individuals within our culture who have difficulty communicating with language include people who are deaf, suffering from mental illness, and children. These individuals are often treated differently by others because they have trouble speaking or using the language. Children are still learning the language, and may be unable to effectively communicate their thoughts and feelings. Although they may be very intelligent, some adults may treat them like they are not, simply because they can't communicate as well. The same could be said about people who are deaf as well. As for people suffering from mental illnesses, the inability to communicate in the same way as others can unfortunately result in them being seen as inferior.
Part 2
I was not able to last the entire 15 minutes without using any type of physical communication, which was quite surprising. I sat on my hands, because I knew I would end up moving them somehow. But what surprised me was how difficult it was to not change my tone of voice or have any facial movements. I realized I raise my eyebrows a lot while I talk, and I am less monotonous than I though.
It was hard for my partner to understand what I was talking about at some points. Without being able to just point or gesture at something and say "Can you hand that to me?", I had to be a lot more specific with my descriptions of items. This was actually kind of frustrating; not only did it take more time to say what I wanted, but sometimes my partner couldn't understand what I meant, and I had to keep describing it in different ways until they understood.
This experiment showed how important physical language is for communication. While spoken language is great for communicating complex or abstract thoughts and ideas, it is a lot easier to just point at something we want. Body language and tone of voice is also important, although a lot of it is subconscious, because it helps convey our feelings and the intent behind our words. There is a great Key and Peele sketch that demonstrates this by showing how people can misinterpret the meaning behind a text message, because there is no tone or body language to show their intent.
There are many people who have trouble reading body language, namely those with autism. Autistic people can have difficulties with picking up on social cues, which are often expressed with body language and tone (frustration, boredom, etc). This can be socially isolating, so being able to read body language would be an adaptive benefit. Humans are naturally social creatures, and are able to survive (and thrive) largely due to helping and working with each other. So being isolated from others could be dangerous.
Part 3
I think the experiment in Part 1 would have been a lot easier if we had been able to use written language. Although writing out thoughts and ideas takes much longer than just speaking them, it would be a lot easier and less time consuming than using only body language and movement.
A culture's written language helps with trade and the economy (receipts, contracts, etc), government administration (e.g. written laws and decrees), long-distance communication (which is important for the economy and government, as well as socially), and education in general.
Written language has helped to spread ideas globally, and not just because of the Internet in modern times. The first developed postal system was established during the Persian Empire around the 6th century BC, which spanned from Turkey to Iraq, where it met up with the Silk Road.



