Tuesday, April 12, 2016

Cultural Descriptions of the Nacerima

I would describe the Nacerima as superstitious, ritualistic, secretive, sadistic, and materialistic.

The Nacerima seem to hold many superstitious beliefs. The human body is debilitated and disease-ridden; the only way to prevent or cure this is to have a ceremonial shrine in the house, which contains magical charms and potions. The Nacerima also believe that the mouth impacts all social interactions, and that demons reside in the heads of the bewitched.

Partially as a result of these superstitious beliefs, the Nacerima have developed several rituals. Daily body rituals, practiced by each family member, occur in the shrine. These rituals include a rite of ablution at the font, and ritual of the mouth involving hog hairs and magical powder. There is also an annual (sometimes bi-annual) ritual performed by a holy-mouth-man, who uses various objects to exorcise the evils in the mouth. Those who are very sick must go to the community's latipso for complex rituals involving magic wands and needles, and daily ablutions performed by vestal maidens.

Most of these rituals are considered secretive, especially those that are performed daily in the household shrine. The rituals are only discussed with young children to teach them the rites. Reproduction and intercourse are also secretive and considered taboo.

The rituals performed by the holy-mouth-men and medicine men show the sadistic nature of the Nacerima; both use a variety of probes on their patients. The holy-mouth-men use these tools to enlarge or gouge out holes in teeth, often poking exposed nerves. Men perform a daily ritual of lacerating their face with a sharp tool, and women bake their heads in ovens.

The Nacerima are also materialistic. Their economy is a developed market, which is central to their daily lives and rituals. Household shrines reflect a family's social status. Additionally, one of their core beliefs is that the human body is ugly. Many daily rituals developed to change this, including the daily mouth rites. Women with "hyper-mammary development" are idolized. This is a reflection of their idea of the perfect human form, which is practically not possible.

1.  For the most part, I think my descriptive words of the Nacerima still apply to Americans. I think Americans are very materialistic; the whole economy revolves around largely unregulated markets and consumerism. Americans can also be ritualistic, as many of us do have a regular daily schedule (which can be interpreted as daily rituals). Although these rituals aren't necessarily developed from superstitious beliefs as I stated before, but are instead performed for either hygiene or health purposes, or because of our market/economy driven lifestyle. Americans can also be relatively private and secretive, especially when it comes to topics such as reproduction and intercourse. However, I don't think Americans are sadistic or superstitious (for the most part).
2. The words superstitious and sadistic exhibit ethnocentrism. The word superstitious can be considered derogatory, as the definition states it results from ignorance, fear of the unknown, trust in magic, or a false concepts of cause and effect. Additionally, the superstitious beliefs I had previously described were actually rooted in scientific fact, such as the "magical potions" which were actually medicines (presumably prescribed by doctors). Using the word sadistic could also be considered derogatory and inaccurate; the "torture" performed by the holy-mouth-men (dentists) was a procedure to improve the health of patients. It could be compared with the modern chemotherapy treatments for cancer patients, which involves highly toxic chemicals.
Materialistic may have been too harsh of a word. I don't think (most) Americans are completely preoccupied with material possessions, but the society as a whole is very consumerist and economy driven. Secretive may also be an exaggeration, although Americans do expect privacy in their lives, and have a few taboo topics such as sexuality.
I think the word ritualistic, using the intended definition for ritual of performing an action the same way in a particular given situation, is an unbiased description. Many Americans have daily rituals, from their morning routine, to following their work/school schedule, to their bedtime routine.
3.  Instead of materialistic, perhaps capitalistic or consumerist would be less biased. Americans aren't quite obsessed with material possessions, which is implied by the use of materialistic. But participating in the economy is very important, which is reflected by capitalistic and consumerist.
Superstitious and sadistic don't really seem to apply anymore, after analyzing what some of the descriptions of the Nacerima really meant and the assumptions I had made based on those descriptions. For example, the use of magical potions (prescribed medications) and the belief that the mouth impacts all social interactions (important for basic hygiene) were described in a way that seemed like a very different experience. These supposedly superstitious beliefs are actually rooted in science, and developed out of a need for health and hygiene. This reasoning also applies to the supposedly sadistic actions of the holy-mouth-men (dentists) or men shaving with a sharp tool.
4. It is important to be as unbiased as possible, because ethnocentrism can cause huge misunderstandings, which can have disastrous consequences (even as disastrous as war). Misunderstanding what is meaningful to another culture can lead to us performing actions that offend them, or even harm them.
I don't think it is possible to completely remove one's own cultural bias when looking at another culture. It is almost completely subconscious. Furthermore, it is impossible to experience every single culture or situation in the world, so we will make assumptions based only on what we have experienced, while neglecting those that we have not.

7 comments:

  1. Five submissions noted and points awarded. Full comments and score will be posted after Part B is submitted.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your choice of the word "materialistic" is a perfect describer of current American culture. I chose this word myself, feeling that the self-centered nature of the culture Miner was describing had led to the building of a society so focused on the "self" that their seems to be little else that they value. I would say that our American markets fall under incredible scrutiny and regulation, to the point of choking out many businesses and that there seems to be a shift taking place that is altering our focus as a society from "profits are king" to "worker is king." but that's a subject for a different class.

    Thanks,
    Marc

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You avoided the problem with ethnocentrism for a couple of your descriptors by choosing words that could fairly be applied to all cultures, namely "ritualistic" and "materialistic". All cultures practice certain rituals and humans are tool makers... they have always valued "things". The first hominids to save their tools for a second use were the first to be "materialistic".

    I think you avoid it with 'secretive' as well since you don't seem to be comparing the culture of Nacerima with any other culture, just upon the practices described by Minor.

    I suggest that "sadistic" and "superstitious" fell into the trap of ethnocentrism, as they were both chosen based upon a false understanding of the practices and their purposes. Is is superstitious to brush our teeth every day or does it make sense to keep our teeth healthy? Is it sadistic to go to the dentist to be poked and prodded or is that logical given the benefit of dental hygiene? When you cast judgment based upon an incomplete understanding of a culture, you "fill in the holes" of your knowledge with your own experiences, which won't necessarily apply to the other culture. That is ethnocentrism.

    "Superstitious and sadistic don't really seem to apply anymore, after analyzing what some of the descriptions of the Nacerima really meant and the assumptions I had made based on those descriptions."

    Which gets to my last comment.

    "Misunderstanding what is meaningful to another culture can lead to us performing actions that offend them, or even harm them."

    Very good point, but since this is a cultural anthropology class, can we be more specific about the dangers of ethnocentrism in this course? How might ethnocentrism negatively impact the conclusions a cultural anthropologist might draw about another culture? Could we consider those conclusions reliable and factual if they started from a place of bias?

    Good final section.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hello Caitlin,
    I also made the mistake of using the descriptive words sadistic and superstitious. and I have to commend you for admitting that the use of the words sadistic and superstitious can be considered derogatory and exhibit a great deal of ethnocentrism. Removing bias opinions can lead to a greater understanding and I congratulate you on a fantastic post.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hello Caitlin!

    I agree that the Nacerima people were quite superstitious. However, this would be considered a bias term; due to limited ethnocentrism. Being that you were raised in a different culture, the cultural experience can be quite disturbing. You brought up many good valid points. For example, as a Cultural Anthropologists it is important that you are unbiased. In reality, that can be difficult in some cases.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello Caitlin!

    I agree that the Nacerima people were quite superstitious. However, this would be considered a bias term; due to limited ethnocentrism. Being that you were raised in a different culture, the cultural experience can be quite disturbing. You brought up many good valid points. For example, as a Cultural Anthropologists it is important that you are unbiased. In reality, that can be difficult in some cases.

    ReplyDelete