The people of the Upper Paleolithic lived in relatively small hunting groups, and were surrounded by both herd animals and predators. This helps explain why depictions of humans in their cave paintings is so rare; interactions with people were not as common as they were with animals. In addition, as stated above, the main function of these paintings is to perform imitative magic, in an attempt to control their interactions with animals.
The artists developed different techniques in order to accommodate the types of rock support in the caves. Artists drew on the walls covered with layers of hard, rough, white calcite. Walls that were brittle, corroded limestone had to be engraved on, and pigmented using the spray technique. This process involved blowing powdered or liquid pigment onto the wall. The artists also used the wall shapes to their advantage by transforming them into the animal or human shapes they wished to draw.
Scaffolding was sometimes used to gain access to the higher portions of the cave walls. To solve the lack of light in the caves, the artists used what may be the first lamp, a sandstone box which used combustible animal fat.
This cave art could have served a religious function. Music may have accompanied the art, which could be depicting their spirit world, in ceremonies. The art may have been a social function; footprints of both adult and children were found near the paintings, which could indicate children's initiation ceremonies into adulthood. As stated above, the cave paintings may have a magical function, in the form of sympathetic or imitative magic.
One of the biggest commonalities in function between the art of early humans and modern humans is the religious function of art. A large amount of art made by modern humans, across all cultures, concerns their respective religions, from figures of Buddha to the paintings of the Renaissance. For example, Hindus pray to and perform ceremonies with statues of their gods.
My favorite artwork is The Starry Night by Vincent van Gogh. This is a post-impressionism piece, which emphasizes the abstract and symbolic. Post-Impressionists paint real subject matter, but distort its forms and use unnatural colors for expression.
Post-Impressionists communicate what they are thinking and feeling, rather than simply showing how something is or looks. It is a fairly broad art movement that occurred in the late 1800s, and doesn't have a cohesive definition of its art style. It was a reaction to the Impressionist art movement, which emphasized natural light, color, etc, rather than symbolism.
I believe all forms of art, from paintings and music to video games and movies, benefit society. No matter the form, art provides an outlet of expression for the artists, and causes its viewers to think and look inward for a meaning.

"...these seemingly sacred locations probably reflect their supernatural beliefs."
ReplyDeleteIs there actually evidence that these caves are "sacred" and they are expressing supernatural beliefs? Or are you imposing that view onto these paintings based upon preconceptions? Likewise, what evidence do you have that they were performing 'magic' of any kind?
Back up and look at this from a more straight-forward perspective, without speculating upon a belief in anything spiritual before we actually have evidence of spiritual belief. Can these drawings be explained without that added spiritual assumption thrown into the mix?
One of the suggestions in the text version of this is that these caves represent a calendar of sorts, a record of herds of animals and events during different times of the year. Can you see how a system of record keeping, to track herds of animals and record successful seasons, to perhaps make predictions on what animals to expect throughout the year, would have a clear survival benefit to this population, with no spiritual benefit necessary? Try to think like an early human, and don't make any assumptions unless they are well supported by the evidence.
I agree with your reasoning on the relative rarity of human figures in the images, but again, no need to resort to an explanation of "magic" to explain this, unless it is supported by the evidence. I imagine that if human populations were of higher density, and if they were coming into more conflict with other humans and needed to remember who to avoid, those humans would have started popping up on the walls.
Good description of their possible painting techniques. Is there anything else, regarding other aspects their culture, that you can decipher from their paintings and engravings?
Good discussion on the difficulties of painting in these caves.
For your functions, you tend to focus on more ephemeral functions. How about more concrete functions that directly impact their survival? Recording data of herds and events, teaching younger generations of their history? Story-telling is part of that, and can an entertainment component along with the educational/historical aspect. Remember that religion and spirituality are relatively recent adaptations of human populations. You can't make the assumption that it was always there and is automatically the reason for the painting's existence just because it would make sense in our modern times. Think like an early human trying to survive and protect his family.
With regard to commonalities, I'm not going to repeat my points on assuming a religious component. Yes, art can reflect religious belief, but can you think of secular explanations to don't require the unsupported assumption that spirituality existed in this population?
Good discussion on your choice of an art form, including it's function and contributions to society.
Note on timing: This cave dates back 350,000 years ago. The earliest evidence of religious concepts is not until about 225,000 years ago in grave sites.
DeleteHi Caitlin,
ReplyDeleteI liked how you stated that cave art could have served as a religious function. I thought maybe in those times there would have not been a concept of religion, but rather spirituality. The stars in the sky were the cave dwellers way of thinking that there was something higher than their existence. I definitely agree that these paintings could have been used as a social function. Perhaps some sort of story telling to the kids from the adults. I loved the artwork that you chose to represent. I love Van Gogh and have always wanted to see The Starry Night in person. Great post!
Marlon
Hello Caitlin,
ReplyDeleteI too thought that the cave paintings were mostly animals because that's what the artists were around all the time and they were just depicting their environment. I never really thought about the religious aspect, I guess I didn't think they had religion back then. I would think that they would be too busy surviving. Van Gogh is one of my favorites too, right behind Dali. Love the picture, I enjoyed reading your post.