The Yanomamo don't have any formal laws or judicial system to speak of, unlike most Western cultures. An individual of the Yanomamo is expected to resolve their own conflicts, rather than turn to the laws which would apply to and solve the situation. Western cultures typically arrest a suspected killer, have a trial, and then punish them if found guilty The Yanomamo use a very different deterrent: the promise of swift and brutal revenge killings.
If someone is killed, the village splits into two new groups and start raiding each other. The raiding parties range from 10 to 20 men. Usually there are only a couple of victims per raid; the raiders ambush intended victims with arrows then run away.
Yanomamo men who have killed perform a ritual of purification and become unokais. The entire village, as well as many of the nearby villages, know who the unokais are, and who they killed to become one. Unokais are seen as valiant and aggressive (a positive quality in Yanomamo culture), so having this status known to everyone could be very beneficial for improving social standing. In addition, those who do not ever become unokais are often seen as cowardly and weak. The obvious benefit to not becoming an unokais is a (highly) decreased risk of getting injured or killed.
Political status, social/economic status, and marriage/reproduction all depend heavily on kinship relationships, especially in tribal groups and communities like the Yanomamo. Kinship groups pool and redistribute resources, and protect members from violence and coercion. Marriages must occur between members of different patrilineal descent groups, so the kinship group one belongs to decides their marriage opportunities.
When a fission occurs in the village due to a killing, individuals may have to choose between their closest kin or their marriage partner (and their kin). Having to choose which "side" to stay on can put them in a difficult position, as it not only affects their personal relationships with kin and their marriage, but it also affects their political and socioeconomic status.
Although it is largely agreed by most people and cultures that killing others is bad, and there are laws with punishments/deterrents in place, murders still happen fairly frequently. They may occur because of a lack of resources (money, food, water, etc) and sexual issues such as infidelity.
Submitted late for half-credit. Comments not submitted on time. If submitted late, please email the instructor to identify the students where comments were posted.
ReplyDeleteThe Yanomamo may not have formal laws as we do but that doesn't mean they don't have rules of behavior. There is a standard of behavior and there are social punishments for breaking from those standards, just like in our society.
There is a lot more to the story of the Yanomamo and how violence is a part of their culture. Expand.
Are their reproductive costs and benefits to unokais or non-unokais status?
Section #4 asks how revenge killing impacts all four of the points listed, not how kinship affects all four points.
Okay, so the key point is that there are instances where killing may occur because there is some type of benefit to the act? So we have laws against killing, not because no one would want to kill, but because sometimes they might have a reason to want to?